Foster's Lightweight Guide to Editing

"To make something great, just re-do it, re-do it, re-do it."
– Kevin Kelly

Great writing often starts off as average writing.

It becomes great through a diligent editing process.

Learning to edit both your work and that of your peers is an invaluable step to becoming the writer you want to be. Thankfully, most writers can become good editors by following a few basic principles.

In this short guide, we lay out 8 ways you can up your editing game.

Advice from professional editors. In the boxes below, you’ll find advice and ideas from professional writers and editors who have worked everywhere from The New York Times to The Hustle.

1. Shift into an editor's mindset.

Being an editor is not the same as being a critic.

As an editor, you have to identify what doesn’t work and make constructive suggestions on how to move a piece forward.

Ultimately, an editor and a writer are partners. You don’t need to agree with everything the writer says, but you should at least understand what they are trying to say.

Editing is like therapy; you’re working with the writer to help them find clarity by listening, asking questions, and posing solutions.

When editing a draft, point out what you find concerning or significant. Push the other person to explain their thinking. Ask clarifying questions, request sources for their references, and push them to provide examples that support their ideas.

Writing is a very personal, vulnerable process. You’re on the writer’s team and want to support their goals while productively challenging them on the things you don’t think are helping.

Find a balance between critical feedback and positive feedback. A mountain of “cut this” and “confused” comments are about as useless as a set of blindly supportive “this draft is perfect, nice work!” comments.

Live somewhere in the middle.

2. Clarify the writer’s objective.

It will be nearly impossible to give useful feedback without understanding what a writer is trying to say.

Before you start giving feedback, clarify the writer’s objective. Skim the first few paragraphs, glance over the structure of the piece, and see if you can grasp the key idea or ideas.

Ask yourself, what’s the core idea this draft is trying to convey?

Secondly, focus on the type of feedback the writer is looking for. Oftentimes, the writer already has an intuition about where their draft needs help and they’ll provide editing guidelines.

If the writer specifically says they don’t want copy edits, then don’t correct every small grammatical error.

Try to summarize the piece in a sentence or two. Share your summary with the writer and ask them if they agree.

3. Consider structure.

Once you’re clear on what a writer is trying to communicate, ask yourself if the draft follows a sensible structure.

Have they laid out the story or argument in a coherent way?

While there is no single “right” way to structure a piece, the reader should be left with some basic sense of coherence and order.

Here are a few practical tips:

Rule of thumb: one idea per sentence, per paragraph, and per section. One useful practice is to include a singular idea in each “unit” of writing. Check if there’s a single, clear idea in each sentence, paragraph, and section. This will ensure ideas build on each other, rather than crowd each other out.

(P.S. Make sure paragraphs start with the main idea the rest of the paragraph will support!)

4. Seek clarity.

After establishing the writer’s intention and ensuring the draft is supported by a strong structural base, it’s time to see if the supporting ideas have been communicated clearly.

Here are a few ways you can do this:

Once you’ve highlighted fuzzy ideas, look for opportunities to clean up and simplify the language itself.

More specifically, you can:

Keep it simple.

Read the work out loud. If you read a paragraph out loud, it’s often immediately clear what’s clunky or doesn’t work.
Run the “beer test.” If a sentence is confusing or uses abstract language, ask the writer how they would explain the same idea to a friend over a beer.

5. Highlight anything that caught your attention.

Once a writer’s objectives and supporting ideas are articulated clearly, it’s time to assess the narrative arc of the draft. Ask yourself if the draft is interesting to read.

Most likely, the draft already has a few moments that caught your attention and others that left you wanting more. Highlight both.

Tips:

This will help the writer know what to enhance in their next draft and what to potentially cut.


6. Use formatting to help ideas shine.

When a draft has a clear objective, well-structured ideas that clearly support it, and a powerful narrative that keeps the reader’s attention, the battle is nearly won.

Next, make sure the piece’s formatting helps the best ideas shine.

Here are some simple ways you can add polish:

Make formatting suggestions relative to the medium. If somebody’s writing a chapter for a novel, long paragraphs might be appropriate. If they’re writing an email newsletter, though, they should probably break up long paragraphs for readability.

7. Review style and grammar.

Finally, you can provide feedback on style and grammar.

Free tools like Grammarly and Google Docs’ spelling and grammar check will often catch the most egregious grammatical errors, but you can probably catch errors those tools can’t.

If you spot any obvious grammatical errors, consider making an in-line suggestion that the writer can “accept” and easily incorporate.

To really help out a writer, highlight any sentences that are muddled. Suggest how the writer might want to rephrase them. Not breaking any grammar rules does not guarantee that an idea will be expressed as clearly as possible.

Ultimately, the grammar and style of a piece should serve the ideas the writer is trying to communicate — not the other way around.

Final Thought: Group Editing

If other people are adding comments to a draft, consider replying to some of their feedback with your own.

Did you agree wholeheartedly with a comment another editor left? Reply to the comment and let them (and the writer!) know. In the Foster community, we are big fans of “+1”s!

Did you disagree with something another editor said? Reply to the comment and explain why.

This can help the reader distinguish why something didn’t work at all or for particular readers.


That’s it :)

Happy editing!


Thank you to the professional editors who reviewed early drafts of this: Lindsey Quinn, Paul Smalera, and Sarah Hunt.

And thank you to these Foster community contributors: LaKay Cornell, Charlene Wang, Michael Shafer, Jesse Germinario, Nanya Sudhir, and Lyle McKeany

Additional resources:


Foster is a paid, invite-only community of online writers and industry experts who contribute to each other’s work. Apply now.

Go home or read the blog

Write With Us